Handling Salary Questions in Job Interviews So You Can Negotiate Later

Posted on October 26, 2024 by Sharee Wells, One of Thousands of Career Coaches on Noomii.

You do want to be happy and fulfilled at what you do all day, every day - so money isn’t everything but of course, let’s be real: job interviews are about the money! You’re not volunteering. You’re interviewing to earn a living by trading your expertise for pay. So, you want to be able to address money issues to your best advantage.

Handling salary discussions during job interviews can be a delicate dance, requiring finesse and timing to ensure a successful outcome. When and how to address questions about compensation can significantly impact your candidacy and the overall impression you leave with potential employers. This article explores the art of dealing with salary questions before receiving a job offer. That provides you with strategies to navigate this crucial aspect of the job-seeking process and set yourself up for successful negotiations later.

1. Patience, please.

In the early stages of the job application process, it’s imperative to exercise patience and restraint when it comes to salary questions in interviews. Although some screeners and certainly online applications press you to divulge your salary history or requirements upfront, mentioning compensation in your cover letter, initial phone evaluation, or during the first interview generally is not advised. These early interactions should be dedicated to showcasing your suitability for the role, allowing the employer to become acquainted with your qualifications and potential contributions, and finding out if a specific employer is right for you.

Rather than focusing on salary, use these opportunities to convey your enthusiasm for the position, align your skills with the job requirements, establish a rapport with the hiring team, and find out your potential boss’ priorities. Demonstrating your dedication and genuine interest in the role can set a positive tone for the later stages of the interview process. “Of course I want to make as much as my contributions allow! Still, it’s more important to me at this stage that I understand your priorities, what my experience brings to those priorities, and if we are a fit.” (If you don’t speak like that, use your own words. Never try to sound like someone you are not.)

2. The Second Interview

The second or even third interview is still an interview and is still before you have an offer. By the time you reach the second interview or a more advanced stage of the selection process, it becomes more acceptable to discuss the topic of compensation. Still, it is always better if the employer is the first to discuss the actual salary amount or range being offered. Regardless, it’s essential to approach this conversation with preparation and tact.

Don’t do it without having done your homework and knowing the current range for your position, level, industry, and location. Although there is a move to require those who post job openings to state clearly what the pay range is, that is not required in every state yet.

So, before answering salary questions in your interview, take the opportunity to reiterate your enthusiasm for the position and highlight the strengths and expertise you would bring to the role. Something along these lines can be a good start: “We know that salary is important, but first, I’d really like to know that we’re on the same page as far as the role I’d play and how my skills in _____ will lead to your profitable _______ as they did for my former employer ________ when I ____________.”

The goal is to assure the employer that your interest extends beyond the paycheck and that you are genuinely invested in the opportunity and the organization’s success. To make you an offer they want to like you, find you easy to work with, and trust your competence. Express your commitment to contributing to the company’s goals and growth, reinforcing the idea that your motivation aligns with the broader mission.

3. Provide a Range

When the topic of compensation arises in the interview process, it’s advisable to provide a salary range rather than a specific figure. This approach demonstrates your flexibility and willingness to engage in a constructive negotiation. If the employer initiates the discussion by asking about your salary expectations, frame your response by first expressing your interest in the role and your alignment with the company’s values and objectives.

For example, you might say, “I’m very excited about the opportunity to contribute to your team and help achieve your goals to _____. Regarding compensation, I’m open to discussing a range that reflects the market standards and the responsibilities of the role.” (If you have done your homework like the employer has likely done, this will indicate that you know what the current competitive pay range is for the position and level in your area and won’t have to mention numbers.) If pressed for actual numbers, state the range from your validated research and be prepared to negotiate within that range and for non-salary options.

The problem with stating specific numbers is that it sounds like a price tag to the employer. If you say you expect a salary between $X and $Z and they offer $X or $Y or $Z, how can you then say it’s not enough? Even if it isn’t?

By offering a range, you do allow room for negotiation while also signaling that you are adaptable and amenable to finding a mutually beneficial solution. Still, it’s best if you wait for employers to state the starting price first. They are the ones who know their budget, not you. When pushed, you can also say that you are sure they have a budget for the position and are willing to consider that if they’ll share it with you. But don’t do that without being able to do it with confidence. Flippancy is never a good tactic.

It’s essential to strike a balance between advocating for fair compensation and maintaining a collaborative and positive tone throughout the conversation.

4. Ensure Full Understanding of Job Requirements

Before engaging in discussions about your preferred salary, it’s crucial to have a comprehensive understanding of the job requirements, responsibilities, and expectations. This knowledge enables you to provide a well-informed response and ensures that your salary expectations align with the scope of the role.

If the employer seeks clarification on your preferred salary, you can confidently refer to your understanding of the position’s demands and market standards. For instance, you might say, “Based on my research and the _______ responsibilities for this role, I believe a competitive salary range would be in line with the area’s industry benchmarks.” Again, you have not stated specific numbers and employers know the going rates and their budgets. If you can avoid that, you should. If you cannot avoid it a range is best.

The Bottom Line

Handling salary questions in job interviews requires thought, preparation, patience, and effective communication. By refraining from bringing up salary or discussing it too early, demonstrating your commitment to the role, providing a flexible salary range that reflects industry and location standards, and ensuring a comprehensive understanding of job requirements, you can approach this critical aspect of the interview process with confidence — and leave yourself room to negotiate once you get an offer.

Remember that salary discussions are not solely about financial compensation; they are an opportunity to align your values, skills, and expectations with the organization’s goals and objectives so you can be satisfied with the work you do as well as the pay you earn. By handling salary questions gracefully, you increase your chances of securing a satisfying job offer and can negotiate later for a win-win compensation package

Follow me on Noomii and on LinkedIn to stay tuned in on all things that result in YOU being your own best career advocate!